Custodians of the Throne: On the Problem of "Gender Pluralism" in the Japanese Political Tradition
https://doi.org/10.18384/2949-5164-2025-4-128-139
Abstract
Aim. To reveal the ontological foundations of imperial power in pre-Restoration Japan through a critical analysis of the conceptual frameworks employed in modern Western historiography, which claims to describe a gender-pluralistic model of succession.
Methodology. A critical analysis of narrative sources and archaeological data was conducted. Historical-genetic and comparative methods were applied to deconstruct the examined concepts.
Results. It was established that female rule served as an instrument for ensuring patrilineal succession (uji) in times of dynastic crisis. The power of empresses was temporary and derivative, while the legitimacy of the system (bansei ikkei) was fundamentally based on male-line descent.
Research implications. The study systematizes the critique of anachronistic interpretations and introduces an ontologically grounded approach to analyzing dynastic power. The connection between the principle of uji and the 1889 Imperial Household Law is substantiated to forecast potential implications of future reforms.
About the Author
M. Yu. Sukhanov
Russian State University for the Humanities
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Maxim Yu. Sukhanov – analyst, Ivan Ilyin Higher School of Politics,
Moscow.
References
1. 若井利明。邪馬台国の滅亡。東京：吉川弘文館、2010年
2. 渡辺義弘著『三国志史料研究』中央公論新社、2012年
3. Dugin, A. G. (2024). Westernology: in the direction of sovereign Russian science . in: Bulletin of the State University of Education. Series: History and Political Science, 3, 7–21 . DOi: 10.18384/2949-51642024-3-7-21 (in Russ .) .
4. 井上光貞。日本の古代国家。東京：岩波書店、1971年
5. 久保貴子。近代初期の朝廷の管理：朝廷と幕府の関係の発展。東京：岩田書院、1998年
6. 倉西裕子。日本書紀の真実。東京：講談社、2003年
7. 小川武夫。伏見家の成立：貞房親王•貞常親王 // 関門日記と中世文化。東京：神話社、2009年
8. 岡本健一。山台国の議論。東京：講談社、1995年
9. 岡野友彦。源氏から日本国王へ。東京：講談社、2003年
10. 大原ひとし。仏像の状態に達する女性の理論の認識について//日本上西シロンシュウ：第5。東京：吉川古文館。 142–158 .
11. 大津徹。天皇の歴史。第 1 巻: 神話から歴史へ。東京：講談社（学術文庫）、2017年
12. 令の注釈: // 神帝造法: 国士大系。第22巻。東京：吉川弘文館、1966年
13. 三時代の規定集 // 国史大系。第 12 巻。東京：経済新聞社、1900 年
14. 聖徳太子 // 日本思想: 大系 (日本思想図書館)。第 1 巻。東京: 岩波書店、1970 年
15. 白石太一郎。考:考学からみた政治二重:州都:聖 // 国立歴史民俗博物館研究: 法国。 2003 年、第 108 号、93–118頁
16. 清家暁。副葬品と被葬者の性別 // 雪の山古墳 古:殺編。八日市：八日市市教育委員会、1996 年 . 175–200頁
17. 関義明。桜井茶臼山古墳から出土した石造物 // 桜井茶臼山古墳の研究。大阪：大阪市立大学、2005年 . 95–114頁
18. 平将之。日本中: 聖の社会と仏教: (中世日本の社会と仏教)。東京：塙書房：1992年
19. 竹島宏著『王朝時代皇居史』宇門書院、1936年
20. 田中善之著『古墳時代の親族関係に関する研究：遺骨研究から復元する社会』柏書房、1995年
21. 藤森薫。恋けいしょう: は宇治の理論でおこなわれてきた // 日本を語る: 恋けいしょう: 編。東京：小学館、2007年
22. 橋本政信。近世宮廷貴族の研究。東京：吉川弘文館、2002年
23. 塚口善夫 . 桜井茶臼山古墳とメスリ山古墳の被葬者について . 日本書紀研究 . 1997年 . 第21号 . 69–86頁
24. Varley, H. P., transl. (1980). A Chronicle of Gods and Sovereigns: Jinnō Shōtōki of Kitabatake Chikafusa. NY: Columbia University Press.
25. Akiko Yo. (2014). When Antiquity Meets the Modern: Presenting the Female Rulers in the Making of Japanese History. Abstract at: URL: https://appsv.main.teikyo-u.ac.jp/tosho/shigaku29-14.pdf (accessed: 25.08.2025).
26. Bix, H. P. (2000). Hirohito and the Making of Modern Japan. London, NY: HarperCollins.
27. Bock, F. G. (1985). Classical Learning and Taoist Practices in Early Japan. Tempe: Arizona State University.
28. Bokenkamp, S. R. (2020). Daoism. In: The Cambridge History of China. Vol. 2: The Six Dynasties, 220– 589. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 553–578.
29. Bowring, R. (2016). Review of Jeffrey L. Richey (ed.) Daoism in Japan: Chinese traditions and their influence on Japanese religious culture, London: Routledge 2015. In: Japonica Humboldtiana, 18, 203– 207.
30. Buruma, I. (1995). A Japanese Mirror: Heroes and Villains of Japanese Culture. London: Vintage.
31. Campany, R. F. (2003). On the Very Idea of Religions (In the Modern West and in Early Medieval China). In: History of Religions,42, 287–319.
32. Huffman, J. L. (2010). Japan in world history. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
33. Hirobumi Itō. (1889). Commentaries on the Constitution of the Empire of Japan. Tokyo: Igirisu hōritsu gakkō.
34. Jay, J. W. (1996). Imagining Matriarchy: 'Kingdoms of Women' in Tang China. In: Journal of the American Oriental Society, 116, 220–229.
35. Kishimoto, N. (2013). Dual Kingship in the Kofun Period as Seen from the Keyhole Tombs. In: UrbanScope, 4, 1–21.
36. Philippi, D. L., trans. (1968). Kojiki. Tokyo: University of Tokyo Press.
37. Matsuzono, H. (2010). A Study of 'Miyake' in Medieval Japan. In: Transactions of the Institute for Cultural Studies, 25, 1–31.
38. McKay, N. (2022). More than placeholders: The ‘century of empresses’ against modern succession laws. In: Melbourne Asia Review. Abstract at: https://www.melbourneasiareview.edu.au/more-than-placeholders-the-century-of-empresses-against-modern-succession-laws (accessed: 12.08.2025).
39. Meeks, L. (2011). The Disappearing Medium: Reassessing the Place of Miko in the Religious Landscape of Premodern Japan. In: History of Religions,50, 208–260.
40. Mori, M. (2003). Ancient and Classical Japan: The Dawn of Shinto. In: Shinto – A Short History. London: Routledge, 12–62.
41. Nagaoka, T. (2006). The Political Function of Female Emperors in Ancient Japan. In: Journal of Japanese History, 42, 17–24.
42. Ooms, H. (2009). Imperial Politics and Symbolics in Ancient Japan: The Tenmu Dynasty, 650–800. Honolulu: University of Hawai'i Press.
43. Pei-ying Lin. (2018). The Rebirth Legend of Prince Shōtoku: Buddhist Networks in Ninth Century China and Japan. In: Heirman, A., Meinert, C. & Anderl, Ch., transl. Buddhist Encounters and Identities Across East Asia. Leiden: Brill, 301–319.
44. Richey, J. L. (2021). Daoist Cosmogony in the Kojiki 古事記 Preface. In: Religions. Abstract at: https:// www.mdpi.com/2077-1444/12/9/761 (accessed: 12.08.2025).
45. Shillonu, B.-A. (2006). Will an empress save the Japanese monarchy? In: Japanese Monarchy: Past and Present. London: London School of Economics and Political Science, 1–17.
46. Shillony, B.-A. (2005). Enigma of the Emperors: Sacred Subservience in Japanese History. Folkestone: Global Oriental.
47. Shima, Yo. (1993). On the Discussion of the Japanese Imperial Family. In: The Waseda Journal of General Science, 43, 209–240.
48. Tsunoda, R., Bary de, Wm. T. & Keene, D. (1958). Sources of Japanese Tradition / eds. by NY, London: Columbia University Press.
49. (1981). The Ten Thousand Leaves: A Translation of the Man’yōshū. Vol. 1. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
50. Webb, H. (1968). The Japanese Imperial Institution in the Tokugawa Period. NY: Columbia University Press.
Review
Views:
88
JATS XML
Email this article 